User blog comment:Boboris02/Large number combinatorics II:Trying to prove something interesting/@comment-30118230-20170204183225/@comment-30754445-20170205180601

"Yes, they could be solved easily,but he didn't propose any way of doing that,and thus,it's not helpful"

Ehm.... What?

When people tell you that your problem is using symbols X,Y,Z without defining them properly, that's a pretty big hint at how to solve this specific problem, isn't it?

Of-course, there's a limit to how helpful one can be when 'he can't make heads or tails of your blog post''. '''Do you actually expect us to provide you with definitions for something we ourselves know nothing about? Sorry, but we aren't magicians.

Now, you can argue that we could have made our point in a more sensitive and respectful way (and I apologize for that) but you certainly can't argue that our criticism was useless. I think we did pretty well on the usefulness front, considering our position.

BTW, it is you who asked the people here to give you feedback. So when people actually take the time to do that after your specific request, it is a little strange to accuse us of "bitching". It's not like I or LP are internet trolls looking for victims to bully... We just tried to help.